Skip to the main text
Patron Notes

Standards

Our standards for reviews

Three qualities make a review worth publishing: it is first-hand, it is particular, and it is fair. Reviewers and businesses answer to the same rules.

The marks of a good review

  • From your own dealings. The purchase, hire, booking or quote you describe was yours, and recent: within roughly the past few years.
  • Particular. Name what you bought or had done. Then give the useful facts: the quote against the final bill, the promised date against the real one, and what happened when something went wrong. A fact is worth more to the next customer than any adjective.
  • Fair. Report how you were treated and what took place. Speak as strongly as you wish; insult no one.
  • Of useful length. No fewer than 40 characters and no more than 3,000.

What we decline to publish

  • Conflicts of interest. Reviews from anyone on the company’s payroll or a rival’s, anyone paid by either, and anyone related to them.
  • Rewards. Anything written to earn something: money, a discount, a gift, a ticket in a prize draw, or any other inducement.
  • The wrong subject. Reviews that belong elsewhere: about a different firm, or about the maker of a product, a marketplace seller or a payment provider rather than the business on this page.
  • Repeats. We publish no more than one review of a given company from each reader in any 30-day stretch.
  • Ways to reach people. No links, no email addresses, no telephone numbers, and nothing that names a member of staff in full or tells readers how to contact them.
  • Abuse. Anything that threatens or harasses, hate speech, swearing at individuals, and sexual material.
  • Borrowed or generated text. Copied from elsewhere, or produced by AI tools in place of your own experience.
  • Accusations of crime. Those belong with the authorities; you remain free to describe what happened to you.

Rules for businesses

A business is welcome to invite every one of its customers to write a review. It must not:

  • Offer anything in return for a review, or for a favorable one in particular.
  • Invite only satisfied customers, or dissuade dissatisfied ones from writing.
  • Review its own business or a competitor, or have staff, relatives or agencies do so on its behalf.
  • Press or threaten a reviewer to alter or withdraw a review.

Our rules for businesses take their lead from the US Federal Trade Commission’s rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, codified as 16 CFR Part 465. Any review a business obtains by breaking them comes down.

When we decline a review

Every review written on Patron Notes is read by a moderator before publication. When we decline a review, we record the reason. If you believe we have erred, write to us with the company’s name and the email address you used, and we will look at the decision again.