Skip to the main text
Patron Notes

Method

Our method, in full

How a review reaches the page, how a score is arrived at, and what a company may and may not do.

From submission to publication

Every review written on Patron Notes begins as pending. A moderator weighs it against our review guidelines, then publishes it or declines it. Until it is published, a review appears nowhere on the company’s page and counts for nothing in its score.

Before anything is published, the moderator puts five questions to it:

  • Did this happen to the writer? It must record a first-hand dealing with this particular company, be it an order, a booking, a visit or a quote.
  • Is anyone exposed or endangered? Personal details about staff come out, and so do threats and hate speech.
  • Does it carry links or phone numbers? Those are removed wherever they appear.
  • Is it one voice posing as several, or written from inside a company or a rival? We look for repeated reviews from a single person, and for reviews by a company’s staff or its competitors.
  • Has this reviewer already written about the company in the past 30 days? Only one review per company is accepted from a reviewer in that time.

What a company can do is reply, publicly, to any review. What it cannot do is edit, hide or remove one, or pay to change the way one is treated; an unfavorable review clears moderation on precisely the terms a glowing one does.

How a score is reached

A company’s score is the simple mean of every star rating in its published reviews, given to one decimal place. We estimate nothing, weight nothing by payment and adjust nothing by hand.

A score takes on its color once the company has at least 5 published reviews. Before then the figure is still shown, in grey and marked early, since a handful of reviews can tilt it either way.

WordRangeShown as
Superb4.5 – 5.04.7
Sound4.0 – 4.44.2
Passable3.0 – 3.93.4
Lacking2.0 – 2.92.5
Dismalbelow 2.01.6

Buying and service, scored apart

Each reviewer tells us whether they bought something, requested a quote or had a service carried out. Once enough have answered, a company carries one score for buying and another for service, since a firm can excel at the one and fall short at the other.

The particulars, and fairness on price

Reviewers may also rate candor and communication, price and charges, timeliness and ease, and quality, and may say whether the final bill matched the quote and whether any fees or extras arrived without warning. None of these figures appears until 5 customers have answered the question.

Order in sorted lists

Sorting by rating alone would let a company with three perfect reviews outrank one with forty excellent ones. To prevent that, a sorted list credits every company with 5 imaginary reviews of 3.5 stars before its real ones are counted. As real reviews accumulate they outweigh the imaginary 5, and the company’s standing settles near its true average:

standing = (5 × 3.5 + its stars, summed) ÷ (5 + its reviews, counted)

The ranking decides order and nothing more. The score on a company’s page is always the simple average.

The sources of reviews

  • Written on Patron Notes: composed by the customer here, on this site.
  • Sent in on the company’s own feedback form: the company asked its own customers through its form and forwarded what came back. Anything the company picked out, altered or paid for is refused.
  • First published elsewhere: written by the customer on another review site and reproduced here as it appeared there.

The making of a listing

We build each listing ourselves, from business records we collect and then check: the name, the street address, the telephone number, the website. Closed companies, and listings we can no longer confirm, are hidden from view and never deleted, so that their reviews survive.

A company may claim its listing without charge, to correct its particulars and answer its customers. A claim has no effect on the score.

Raising a concern about a review

Should a review strike you as false, as aimed at the wrong company, or as breaking our guidelines, use the Report link that sits beneath it. Every report is considered by a moderator, and the review remains in place meanwhile; the outcome may be removal, no change, or a request to the author for more detail.